Suspicion if the man's semen rises above the woman's semen
Question:
I came to ask you about something that no one on earth knows except a prophet or a man or two men. He said: It will benefit you if I tell you. He said: I will listen with my ears. He said: I came to ask you about a child. He said: The man’s fluid is white and the woman’s fluid is yellow. So if they come together and the man ’s fluid overtakes the woman ’s fluid, they will produce a boy, God willing. And if the woman ’s fluid overtakes the man’s fluid, they will produce a girl, God willing. The Jew said: You have spoken the truth, and you are indeed a prophet. Then he turned away and left. The Messenger of God, may God bless him and grant him peace, said: This man asked me about what he asked me about, and I had no knowledge of any of it until God brought it to me
. Of course, there are several scientific errors in general, not just one, in this hadith:
saying that the woman’s fluid flowing from her contributes and works in parallel with the man’s fluid in forming the fetus. Of course, this is a grave error, for two reasons:
First: The woman’s egg is responsible for providing the fetus with half of its genetic genes and helping in its formation, and the woman’s fluid has absolutely nothing to do with that.
Second: The woman’s fluid has only one function, which is to moisten and lubricate the vagina to facilitate the entry of the man’s penis inside, and this fluid does not come out.
Answer: Indeed, This doubt only indicates the weakness of the one who brought it up with modern science and also indicates the haste and rashness of its source , as they looked at the hadith and judged it based on the first glance, and the first glance is foolish... If they had known the nature of the vaginal secretions that occur during intercourse and their characteristics, this doubt would not have been sufficient...
First, I present to you, my dear readers, what is well-known in most Islamic forums to explain this hadith scientifically.
The first interpretation... women's water is vaginal secretions
They believe that what is meant by the woman’s water is vaginal secretions and what is meant by the man’s water is the sperm ... and that the man’s water is alkaline and the woman’s water is acidic. So if the two waters meet and the woman’s water prevails over the man’s water, the medium will be acidic , so the movement of the sperm that carry male characteristics will weaken and the sperm that carry female characteristics will succeed in fertilizing the egg, so the baby will be female, and vice versa....
Of course, this is wrong but could be correct... Why?
The first reason : Because the hadith states that a woman’s water is yellow and thin ... while the custardly secretions that occur during intercourse are nothing but thick white or transparent secretions . The evidence for that is as follows:
The first evidence : It is the evidence of sensory observation. Every married man or woman who has reached the age of puberty knows very well that the custardly secretions that occur during intercourse are white or transparent . In fact, a man may become confused during marital intercourse and believe that his wife’s custardly secretions are nothing but semen from him.
The second evidence : is what specialists say that the vaginal secretions that occur during intercourse are white or transparent ... HTTP://WWW.TBEEB.NET/A-650.HTM
Specialists also confirm that the secretions that occur during sexual arousal are white secretions:
THE TERM USED FOR WHITE DISCHARGE IN WOMEN DUE TO SEXUAL INTERCOURSE IS CALLED FEMALE " ORGASM " VAGINAL SECRETIONS, WHICH INCREASES DURING SEXUAL
The second reason: is that there is another hadith of the unlettered prophet that came with the wording “ If the man’s fluid precedes the woman’s fluid … etc .” Here we find that this hadith used the word “preceded ” instead of “ overtook ”… The word “preceded” means to advance or to take the lead in running and in everything … and the two who are racing must have started from one place and are heading to one place … So when I say if Ahmed preceded Mohammed, then Ahmed and Mohammed must have started from one place and are racing to one direction… From here, whoever says that what is meant by the woman’s fluid in the hadith is vaginal secretions must clarify our incorrect understanding of the word “ preceded ” and how the vaginal secretions precede the man’s semen when both are from a different source and what is the direction they are racing towards.
The second interpretation - which I accept - is the egg.
The hadith talked about three things, which are the following:
First : The man's fluid, meaning the seminal fluid .... Someone might ask, is it correct to call it water? Or why is it described as water?
The answer is... Yes, because the percentage of water in the composition of the seminal fluid is very large, estimated at 92%. There are even other sources that confirm that the percentage of water in the seminal fluid is estimated at about 96% , and the number of sperm in it does not exceed 2%, and the rest is other materials .
Is there scientific evidence for that? The answer is yes. Read in this source here what it says:
SPEAKING OF ITS COMPOSITION, SEMEN IS ABOUT 96 PERCENT WATER , PLUS:
• SPERM, WHICH ACCOUNT FOR ABOUT 2 PERCENT OF EJACULATE VOLUME.
• FRUCTOSE, FRUIT SUGAR, WHICH NOURISHES SPERM.
• VITAMIN C, WHICH HELPS KEEP SPERM HEALTHY.
Second : The woman's water , meaning the woman's egg , not the vaginal secretions ... This is because the hadith states that the woman's water is yellow and thin , and these are characteristics that do not agree with the characteristics of the vaginal secretions that we talked about previously... Someone might ask, do the characteristics of the ovum agree with the characteristics mentioned in the hadith about the woman's water?
The answer is yes... This is because water flows from the Graafian follicle in the ovary carrying the egg, and it is yellow in color... And the egg itself is composed mainly of water and is also yellow in color ... It is surrounded by a thick layer of yellow "follicular" cells... and thin so that the sperm can penetrate it.
Is there scientific evidence for this? .... Yes, there is. Read, my dear sir, the following texts that confirm that a woman's egg is composed of water
-A WOMAN'S EGG IS A SINGLE CELL – THE LARGEST IN THE HUMAN BODY – COMPOSED PRIMARILY OF WATER
Translation:
A woman's egg is a single cell - the largest in the human body - composed primarily of water
Source / here
- and also from another source that says
THE HUMAN EGG IS THE LARGEST CELL IN THE BODY AND IS COMPOSED MOSTLY OF WATER,
Translation:
The human egg is the largest cell in the body and is composed mostly of water
Source / here
As for the color of the egg, look all of you gentlemen at the following picture.. It is a real picture of a woman's egg as it emerges from the ovary.. And look at its color: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/ar...ged-ovary.html From here we find that the attributes that the Messenger gave to the woman's water apply completely to the egg... Third : The man's semen And the woman’s sperm... I used the hadith that the phrase “ the man’s sperm ” is
The woman's semen to determine the sex of the fetus instead of the word " water "... So what is meant by the man's semen and the woman's semen are the sperm that carry the male characteristic and the sperm that carry the female characteristic ... What supports this opinion is that there is another hadith of the Messenger, may God bless him and grant him peace, in which he said... "If the man's semen precedes the woman's semen, a male will be born, God willing... etc... And since the hadith used the word preceded, this means that this water came from one source and is heading to one source, which is the egg... And of course it is scientifically known that if the sperm that carries the male characteristic precedes in fertilizing the egg, the child will be male and vice versa ...
In summary of the above ... It becomes clear to the ignorant before the learned that this hadith, which the atheist objected to, imagining that it contains many scientific errors, matches many scientific facts that were not known before ... And God Almighty is true when He said, "He does not speak from [his own] inclination."
First : The man's fluid, meaning the seminal fluid .... Someone might ask, is it correct to call it water? Or why is it described as water?
The answer is... Yes, because the percentage of water in the composition of the seminal fluid is very large, estimated at 92%. There are even other sources that confirm that the percentage of water in the seminal fluid is estimated at about 96% , and the number of sperm in it does not exceed 2%, and the rest is other materials .
Is there scientific evidence for that? The answer is yes. Read in this source here what it says:
SPEAKING OF ITS COMPOSITION, SEMEN IS ABOUT 96 PERCENT WATER , PLUS:
• SPERM, WHICH ACCOUNT FOR ABOUT 2 PERCENT OF EJACULATE VOLUME.
• FRUCTOSE, FRUIT SUGAR, WHICH NOURISHES SPERM.
• VITAMIN C, WHICH HELPS KEEP SPERM HEALTHY.
Second : The woman's water , meaning the woman's egg , not the vaginal secretions ... This is because the hadith states that the woman's water is yellow and thin , and these are characteristics that do not agree with the characteristics of the vaginal secretions that we talked about previously... Someone might ask, do the characteristics of the ovum agree with the characteristics mentioned in the hadith about the woman's water?
The answer is yes... This is because water flows from the Graafian follicle in the ovary carrying the egg, and it is yellow in color... And the egg itself is composed mainly of water and is also yellow in color ... It is surrounded by a thick layer of yellow "follicular" cells... and thin so that the sperm can penetrate it.
Is there scientific evidence for this? .... Yes, there is. Read, my dear sir, the following texts that confirm that a woman's egg is composed of water
-A WOMAN'S EGG IS A SINGLE CELL – THE LARGEST IN THE HUMAN BODY – COMPOSED PRIMARILY OF WATER
Translation:
A woman's egg is a single cell - the largest in the human body - composed primarily of water
Source / here
- and also from another source that says
THE HUMAN EGG IS THE LARGEST CELL IN THE BODY AND IS COMPOSED MOSTLY OF WATER,
Translation:
The human egg is the largest cell in the body and is composed mostly of water
Source / here
As for the color of the egg, look all of you gentlemen at the following picture.. It is a real picture of a woman's egg as it emerges from the ovary.. And look at its color: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/ar...ged-ovary.html From here we find that the attributes that the Messenger gave to the woman's water apply completely to the egg... Third : The man's semen And the woman’s sperm... I used the hadith that the phrase “ the man’s sperm ” is
The woman's semen to determine the sex of the fetus instead of the word " water "... So what is meant by the man's semen and the woman's semen are the sperm that carry the male characteristic and the sperm that carry the female characteristic ... What supports this opinion is that there is another hadith of the Messenger, may God bless him and grant him peace, in which he said... "If the man's semen precedes the woman's semen, a male will be born, God willing... etc... And since the hadith used the word preceded, this means that this water came from one source and is heading to one source, which is the egg... And of course it is scientifically known that if the sperm that carries the male characteristic precedes in fertilizing the egg, the child will be male and vice versa ...
In summary of the above ... It becomes clear to the ignorant before the learned that this hadith, which the atheist objected to, imagining that it contains many scientific errors, matches many scientific facts that were not known before ... And God Almighty is true when He said, "He does not speak from [his own] inclination."
.png)
Comments
Post a Comment