Reply to the suspicion / Leprosy affects humans only on Wednesday
In the name of God, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
O God, guide our aim, bless our deeds, and make them sincere for Your sake.
We say, “And God is the source of help.”
O God, guide our aim, bless our deeds, and make them sincere for Your sake.
We say, “And God is the source of help.”
The previously mentioned hadith is not authentic, as its chain of transmission and text
are not authentic. A Christian might say, “How is it not authentic?” when Al-Albani deemed it good.
So let us look together at the following
narrations of the hadith.
1- Cupping on an empty stomach is best, as it brings healing and blessings. It increases the mind and increases memory.
Narrator: Abdullah bin Omar. Narrator: Abu Hatim al-Razi - Source: al- Ilal by Ibn Abi Hatim - Page or number: 3/421. Summary of the narrator’s ruling: This hadith is nothing , it is not the hadith of the people of truth. 2 - Cupping on an empty stomach is the best in it, it brings healing and blessing. It increases the mind and increases memory and increases the memory of the memorizer. Whoever is cupped on Thursday or Tuesday, for that is the day on which Allah lifted the affliction from Job and struck him on Wednesday and Wednesday night. Narrator: Abdullah bin Omar. Narrator: Ibn Hibban - Source: al-Majruhin - Page or number: 2/355. Summary of the narrator’s ruling: [It contains] al-Muthanna bin Amr narrating from Abu Sinan what is not from the hadith of trustworthy people and it is not permissible to use it as evidence . 3 - Cupping on an empty stomach is the best in it, it brings healing and blessing. It increases the mind and increases memory and increases the memory of the memorizer. Get cupped with the blessing of Allah the Almighty on Thursday, and avoid cupping on Wednesday, Friday, Saturday, and Sunday, and get cupped on Monday. And Tuesday is the day on which Allah the Almighty cured Job from the affliction on Tuesday, and Allah the Almighty struck with the affliction on Wednesday, and leprosy and vitiligo do not appear except on Wednesday. Narrator: Abdullah bin Omar Narrator: Ibn Hibban - Source: Al- Majruhin - Page or number: 2/74 Summary of the narrator’s ruling: [It contains] Uthman bin Matar narrating fabricated hadiths from reliable sources, it is not permissible to use him as evidence . 4 - Cupping on an empty stomach is best, and in it is healing and blessing, and it increases the mind and increases the memory and increases the memory of the memorizer, and cupping is done on Thursday with Allah’s blessing, and avoid cupping on Wednesday, Friday, Saturday, and Sunday, and cupping is done on Monday and Tuesday, for it is the day on which Allah cured Job from the affliction. Meaning Tuesday, and leprosy and vitiligo do not start until Wednesday Narrator: Abdullah bin Omar Narrator: Ibn Adi - Source: Al- Kamil fi Al-Du'afa - Page or number: 3/141 Summary of the narrator's ruling: Perhaps the affliction is from Uthman bin Matar 5 - Cupping on an empty stomach is best Narrator: Abdullah bin Omar Narrator: Ibn Al-Qaysarani - Source: Tadhkirat Al-Huffaz - Page or number: 413 Summary of the narrator's ruling: Topic 6 - Cupping on an empty stomach is best and in it is healing and blessing, and increases the mind and increases memory and increases the memory of the memorizer, and cup with the blessing of Allah on Thursday and avoid cupping on Wednesday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday and cup on Monday and Tuesday because it is the day on which Allah cured Job from the affliction, meaning Tuesday, and leprosy and vitiligo do not start until Wednesday Narrator: Abdullah bin Omar Narrator:
Ibn al-Qaysarani - Source: Dhakhirat al-Huffaz - Page or number: 3/1252 Summary of the hadith scholar’s ruling: It includes Uthman ibn Matar, perhaps the affliction is from him. 7 - Cupping on an empty stomach is best. Narrator: - The hadith scholar: Ibn al-Qaysarani - Source: Ma’rifat al-Tadhkira - Page or number: 263 Summary of the hadith scholar’s ruling: It includes Uthman ibn Matar al-Shaibani, he is a liar. 8 - Cupping on an empty stomach is best, and it is a cure and a blessing, and increases the mind and memory. Have cupping done on Thursday with Allah’s blessing, and avoid cupping on Wednesday, Friday, Saturday, and Sunday, and be careful. Have cupping done on Monday and Tuesday, for it is the day on which Allah healed Job and struck him with affliction on Wednesday, for leprosy and vitiligo do not appear except on Wednesday and Wednesday night. Narrator: Abdullah ibn Umar The hadith scholar: al-Mundhiri - Source: al-Targheeb wa’t-Tarheeb - Page or number: 4/244 Summary of the hadith scholar’s ruling: [Narrated] on the authority of Sa’eed ibn Maimun, and I do not recall any criticism or approval of him. On the authority of Nafi’, and on the authority of Al-Hasan bin Abi Ja’far, on the authority of Muhammad bin Jahada, on the authority of Nafi’, and the discussion of Al-Hasan and Muhammad will come, and on the authority of Abdullah bin Saleh
9 - Cupping on an empty stomach is best, it brings healing and blessing, it increases the mind and memory...
Narrator: Abdullah bin Omar Narrator: Al-Dhahabi - Source: Mizan Al-I'tidal - Page or number: 3/435 Summary of the narrator's ruling: [It contains] Al-Muthanna bin Amr. Ibn Hibban said: It is not permissible to use him as evidence. 10 - Cupping on an empty stomach is best, it brings healing and blessing, it increases the mind and memory... Narrator: Abdullah bin Omar Narrator: Al-Dhahabi - Source: Mizan Al-I'tidal - Page or number: 3/54 Summary of the narrator's ruling: [It contains Uthman bin Matar, who was weakened by more than one person] 11 - Cupping on an empty stomach is best and in it is healing and blessing and increases the mind and memory, so have cupping done with the blessing of Allah on Thursday and avoid cupping on Wednesday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday, and be careful and have cupping done on Monday and Tuesday, for it is the day on which Allah cured Job from the affliction and struck him with the affliction on Wednesday, for leprosy and vitiligo do not appear except on Wednesday or Wednesday night. Narrator: Abdullah bin Omar Narrator: Al-Albani - Source: Sahih Ibn Majah - Page or number: 2825 Summary of the narrator's ruling: Hasan 12 - Cupping on an empty stomach is best and it increases the mind and increases the memory and increases the memory of the memorizer, so whoever has cupping done on Thursday in the name of Allah and avoid cupping on Friday, Saturday and Sunday and have cupping done on Monday and Tuesday and avoid cupping on Wednesday, for it is the day 13 - Cupping on an empty stomach is best , and in it is healing and blessing, and it increases the mind and memory, so have cupping done with Allah ’s blessing on Thursday, and avoid cupping on Wednesday, Friday, Saturday, and Sunday, and be careful, and have cupping done on Monday and Tuesday, because it is the day on which Allah cured Job from the affliction, and struck him with the affliction on Wednesday, so leprosy and vitiligo do not appear except on Wednesday or Wednesday night. Narrator: Abdullah bin Omar Hadith scholar: Al-Albani - Source: As-Silsilah As-Saheehah - Page or number: 766 Summary of the Hadith scholar’s ruling: Hasan according to others 14 - Cupping on an empty stomach is best, and in it is healing and blessing, and it increases the mind and memory, and have cupping done with Allah’s blessing on Thursday, and avoid cupping on Wednesday and Friday Saturday and Sunday, be careful, and have cupping done on Monday and Tuesday, because it is the day on which God healed Job and struck him with affliction on Wednesday, because leprosy and vitiligo do not appear except on Wednesday and Wednesday night.
Narrator: Abdullah bin Omar Narrator of Hadith: Al-Albani - Source: Sahih Al-Targheeb - Page or number: 3466 Summary of the narrator’s ruling: Hasan li ghayrihi 15 - Cupping on an empty stomach is best, and it brings healing and blessing, and increases memory and reason, so have cupping done on Thursday with the blessing of Allah, and avoid cupping on Friday, Saturday, and Sunday, and have cupping done on Monday and Tuesday, for it is the day on which Allah cured Job from his affliction, and avoid cupping on Wednesday, for it is the day on which Allah cured Job from his affliction. It is the day that Job was tested, and leprosy and vitiligo do not appear except on Wednesday, or on Wednesday night. Narrator: Abdullah bin Omar. Narrator: Al-Albani - Source: Sahih Al-Jami - Page or number: 3169 Summary of the narrator’s ruling: Hasan, as you can see, Al-Albani alone is one of the Hasan of hadith. As for those who denied it, they are Ibn Hibban, Ibn Adi , Ibn Al-Jawzi , Al- Dhahabi, Ibn Hajar, and Al -Shawkani . Ibn Al-Jawzi mentioned it in Al-Ilal Al-Mutanahiyyah , Al-Sakhawi, Ibn Tahir Al-Maqdisi, Ibn Abi Hatim, and Abi Hatim said that this hadith is nothing . Al-Hakim mentioned it in Al-Mustadrak and criticized it. Al-Hafiz Abu Hatim Al-Razi weakened it. Al-Suyuti Sheikh / Abu Omar Al-Otaibi graduated the methods of hadith in his research (The fabricated hadiths that contradict the oneness of worship, collection and study) and others. It must be taken into consideration that Al-Albani did not authenticate the hadith, but rather ( it was Hasan ).The hadith here is not proven and has problems. Some scholars weakened itand most of the scholars mentioned above denied it because it is defective and its narrators Some of them are liars, some are not reliable, and only one of them is good.Therefore, there is no scientific objection at all to the hadiths of the Messenger, may God...In order for the one who raises doubts to be correct, he must provide a contradiction between what the scholars have agreedto be correct and an established scientific fact.
Narrator: Abdullah bin Omar. Narrator: Abu Hatim al-Razi - Source: al- Ilal by Ibn Abi Hatim - Page or number: 3/421. Summary of the narrator’s ruling: This hadith is nothing , it is not the hadith of the people of truth. 2 - Cupping on an empty stomach is the best in it, it brings healing and blessing. It increases the mind and increases memory and increases the memory of the memorizer. Whoever is cupped on Thursday or Tuesday, for that is the day on which Allah lifted the affliction from Job and struck him on Wednesday and Wednesday night. Narrator: Abdullah bin Omar. Narrator: Ibn Hibban - Source: al-Majruhin - Page or number: 2/355. Summary of the narrator’s ruling: [It contains] al-Muthanna bin Amr narrating from Abu Sinan what is not from the hadith of trustworthy people and it is not permissible to use it as evidence . 3 - Cupping on an empty stomach is the best in it, it brings healing and blessing. It increases the mind and increases memory and increases the memory of the memorizer. Get cupped with the blessing of Allah the Almighty on Thursday, and avoid cupping on Wednesday, Friday, Saturday, and Sunday, and get cupped on Monday. And Tuesday is the day on which Allah the Almighty cured Job from the affliction on Tuesday, and Allah the Almighty struck with the affliction on Wednesday, and leprosy and vitiligo do not appear except on Wednesday. Narrator: Abdullah bin Omar Narrator: Ibn Hibban - Source: Al- Majruhin - Page or number: 2/74 Summary of the narrator’s ruling: [It contains] Uthman bin Matar narrating fabricated hadiths from reliable sources, it is not permissible to use him as evidence . 4 - Cupping on an empty stomach is best, and in it is healing and blessing, and it increases the mind and increases the memory and increases the memory of the memorizer, and cupping is done on Thursday with Allah’s blessing, and avoid cupping on Wednesday, Friday, Saturday, and Sunday, and cupping is done on Monday and Tuesday, for it is the day on which Allah cured Job from the affliction. Meaning Tuesday, and leprosy and vitiligo do not start until Wednesday Narrator: Abdullah bin Omar Narrator: Ibn Adi - Source: Al- Kamil fi Al-Du'afa - Page or number: 3/141 Summary of the narrator's ruling: Perhaps the affliction is from Uthman bin Matar 5 - Cupping on an empty stomach is best Narrator: Abdullah bin Omar Narrator: Ibn Al-Qaysarani - Source: Tadhkirat Al-Huffaz - Page or number: 413 Summary of the narrator's ruling: Topic 6 - Cupping on an empty stomach is best and in it is healing and blessing, and increases the mind and increases memory and increases the memory of the memorizer, and cup with the blessing of Allah on Thursday and avoid cupping on Wednesday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday and cup on Monday and Tuesday because it is the day on which Allah cured Job from the affliction, meaning Tuesday, and leprosy and vitiligo do not start until Wednesday Narrator: Abdullah bin Omar Narrator:
Ibn al-Qaysarani - Source: Dhakhirat al-Huffaz - Page or number: 3/1252 Summary of the hadith scholar’s ruling: It includes Uthman ibn Matar, perhaps the affliction is from him. 7 - Cupping on an empty stomach is best. Narrator: - The hadith scholar: Ibn al-Qaysarani - Source: Ma’rifat al-Tadhkira - Page or number: 263 Summary of the hadith scholar’s ruling: It includes Uthman ibn Matar al-Shaibani, he is a liar. 8 - Cupping on an empty stomach is best, and it is a cure and a blessing, and increases the mind and memory. Have cupping done on Thursday with Allah’s blessing, and avoid cupping on Wednesday, Friday, Saturday, and Sunday, and be careful. Have cupping done on Monday and Tuesday, for it is the day on which Allah healed Job and struck him with affliction on Wednesday, for leprosy and vitiligo do not appear except on Wednesday and Wednesday night. Narrator: Abdullah ibn Umar The hadith scholar: al-Mundhiri - Source: al-Targheeb wa’t-Tarheeb - Page or number: 4/244 Summary of the hadith scholar’s ruling: [Narrated] on the authority of Sa’eed ibn Maimun, and I do not recall any criticism or approval of him. On the authority of Nafi’, and on the authority of Al-Hasan bin Abi Ja’far, on the authority of Muhammad bin Jahada, on the authority of Nafi’, and the discussion of Al-Hasan and Muhammad will come, and on the authority of Abdullah bin Saleh
quote:
| Abdullah bin Saleh I found in the book of the wounded of the hadith scholars and the weak and abandoned, Vol. 2, p. 40, by Imam Al-Hafiz Muhammad bin Hibban, edited by Mahmoud Ibrahim Zayed / Dar Al-Wa’i / Aleppo 1395 - 1975 I heard Omar bin Muhammad say I heard Muhammad bin Isa say I heard Ziyad bin Ayoub say: Ahmad bin Hambal, may God have mercy on him, forbade me from narrating the hadith of Abdullah bin Saleh I heard Ibn Khuzaymah say: He had a neighbor between whom and him there was enmity, so he used to fabricate the hadith on the authority of the sheikh of Abdullah bin Saleh and write it on a piece of paper in a handwriting similar to the handwriting of Abdullah bin Saleh and throw it in his house among his books, and Abdullah would find it and narrate it, thinking that it was his handwriting and his hearing. So from this perspective, the strange things occurred in his narrations. End . |
9 - Cupping on an empty stomach is best, it brings healing and blessing, it increases the mind and memory...
Narrator: Abdullah bin Omar Narrator: Al-Dhahabi - Source: Mizan Al-I'tidal - Page or number: 3/435 Summary of the narrator's ruling: [It contains] Al-Muthanna bin Amr. Ibn Hibban said: It is not permissible to use him as evidence. 10 - Cupping on an empty stomach is best, it brings healing and blessing, it increases the mind and memory... Narrator: Abdullah bin Omar Narrator: Al-Dhahabi - Source: Mizan Al-I'tidal - Page or number: 3/54 Summary of the narrator's ruling: [It contains Uthman bin Matar, who was weakened by more than one person] 11 - Cupping on an empty stomach is best and in it is healing and blessing and increases the mind and memory, so have cupping done with the blessing of Allah on Thursday and avoid cupping on Wednesday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday, and be careful and have cupping done on Monday and Tuesday, for it is the day on which Allah cured Job from the affliction and struck him with the affliction on Wednesday, for leprosy and vitiligo do not appear except on Wednesday or Wednesday night. Narrator: Abdullah bin Omar Narrator: Al-Albani - Source: Sahih Ibn Majah - Page or number: 2825 Summary of the narrator's ruling: Hasan 12 - Cupping on an empty stomach is best and it increases the mind and increases the memory and increases the memory of the memorizer, so whoever has cupping done on Thursday in the name of Allah and avoid cupping on Friday, Saturday and Sunday and have cupping done on Monday and Tuesday and avoid cupping on Wednesday, for it is the day 13 - Cupping on an empty stomach is best , and in it is healing and blessing, and it increases the mind and memory, so have cupping done with Allah ’s blessing on Thursday, and avoid cupping on Wednesday, Friday, Saturday, and Sunday, and be careful, and have cupping done on Monday and Tuesday, because it is the day on which Allah cured Job from the affliction, and struck him with the affliction on Wednesday, so leprosy and vitiligo do not appear except on Wednesday or Wednesday night. Narrator: Abdullah bin Omar Hadith scholar: Al-Albani - Source: As-Silsilah As-Saheehah - Page or number: 766 Summary of the Hadith scholar’s ruling: Hasan according to others 14 - Cupping on an empty stomach is best, and in it is healing and blessing, and it increases the mind and memory, and have cupping done with Allah’s blessing on Thursday, and avoid cupping on Wednesday and Friday Saturday and Sunday, be careful, and have cupping done on Monday and Tuesday, because it is the day on which God healed Job and struck him with affliction on Wednesday, because leprosy and vitiligo do not appear except on Wednesday and Wednesday night.
Narrator: Abdullah bin Omar Narrator of Hadith: Al-Albani - Source: Sahih Al-Targheeb - Page or number: 3466 Summary of the narrator’s ruling: Hasan li ghayrihi 15 - Cupping on an empty stomach is best, and it brings healing and blessing, and increases memory and reason, so have cupping done on Thursday with the blessing of Allah, and avoid cupping on Friday, Saturday, and Sunday, and have cupping done on Monday and Tuesday, for it is the day on which Allah cured Job from his affliction, and avoid cupping on Wednesday, for it is the day on which Allah cured Job from his affliction. It is the day that Job was tested, and leprosy and vitiligo do not appear except on Wednesday, or on Wednesday night. Narrator: Abdullah bin Omar. Narrator: Al-Albani - Source: Sahih Al-Jami - Page or number: 3169 Summary of the narrator’s ruling: Hasan, as you can see, Al-Albani alone is one of the Hasan of hadith. As for those who denied it, they are Ibn Hibban, Ibn Adi , Ibn Al-Jawzi , Al- Dhahabi, Ibn Hajar, and Al -Shawkani . Ibn Al-Jawzi mentioned it in Al-Ilal Al-Mutanahiyyah , Al-Sakhawi, Ibn Tahir Al-Maqdisi, Ibn Abi Hatim, and Abi Hatim said that this hadith is nothing . Al-Hakim mentioned it in Al-Mustadrak and criticized it. Al-Hafiz Abu Hatim Al-Razi weakened it. Al-Suyuti Sheikh / Abu Omar Al-Otaibi graduated the methods of hadith in his research (The fabricated hadiths that contradict the oneness of worship, collection and study) and others. It must be taken into consideration that Al-Albani did not authenticate the hadith, but rather ( it was Hasan ).The hadith here is not proven and has problems. Some scholars weakened itand most of the scholars mentioned above denied it because it is defective and its narrators Some of them are liars, some are not reliable, and only one of them is good.Therefore, there is no scientific objection at all to the hadiths of the Messenger, may God...In order for the one who raises doubts to be correct, he must provide a contradiction between what the scholars have agreedto be correct and an established scientific fact.
.png)
Comments
Post a Comment